At Sweet Amanda Leigh, we pride ourselves on uniquely creative and delicious custom designed cakes, cookies, and sweets, made from the finest ingredients available. With our extensive selection of cake flavors, frostings, and fillings, we can help you create a combination that will delight your taste buds and your imagination. Have a question or don’t see what you are looking for? Contact us, we are happy to answer your questions and will work with you to create a custom creation that meets your exact needs.

Cake Flavors:

  • Deep Chocolate - moist and rich with a deep cocoa flavor
  • Classic Vanilla - pure, natural vanilla creates a sweet taste that’s anything but plain
  • Coconut Cake - decadent, moist, and full of coconut loveliness
  • Velvet Cake - a perfect melody of cocoa and vanilla with a velvety texture
  • Lemon Butter Cake - fresh and zesty, it’s lemony goodness in cake form
  • Carrot Cake - dense, moist, and perfectly spiced (can be made with or without nuts)
  • Almond Gossamer - reminiscent of Sweet Amanda Leigh's signature rainbow cookies
  • Funfetti - moist white cake with the colors of the rainbow dotted throughout. 
  • Banana Chip - flavorful, moist and perfect with peanut butter frosting

Frostings and Fillings:

  • Vanilla Buttercream - perfect amount of sweetness and tons of vanilla  
  • Chocolate Fudge Buttercream - rich chocolate with a creamy, mousse-like texture
  • Swiss Meringue Buttercream - velvety butter finish and less sweetness than our other frostings - available in vanilla, chocolate or mocha
  • Toffee Buttercream - our signature vanilla buttercream with swirls of rich nutty homemade toffee sauce 
  • Toasted Marshmallow - bits of campfire caramel crunch
  • Apricot or Raspberry Preserves
  • Seasonal Preserves - Please ask us what fruit is in season to help you create a delicious and one of a kind cake.
  • Cream Cheese Frosting* - sweet and rich with just a hint of tanginess




Each cake is unique and therefore cakes are priced according to complexity of design, sculpting, painting, piping, gumpaste flowers and any other time-consuming design elements.

  1. Wedding and Custom cakes start at $150. (minimum of 22 servings) - These cakes are tiered (stacked upon eachother) and exquisite. They create the perfect canvas to reflect your personal style.
  2. Novelty and Sculpted cakes start at $10 per serving. (minimum of 35 servings) - Novelty and sculpted cakes are hand carved creating an edible 3 dimensional sculpture that is sure to be the centerpiece of any party!


For more information please contact us at either or (646) 770-2066.

* Not available in any hand carved cake due to the delicate nature of the ingredients.